How the choice is actually made
Owners often ask which system is best, as though there were one answer. On a real building the decision falls out of four questions, in this order.
- What is already up there. The number of existing layers, whether the insulation is dry and what the deck is made of rule options in or out before anything else. A roof carrying two layers of covering cannot simply take a third.
- What the roof has to put up with. Grease exhaust from a kitchen, constant service traffic around equipment, ponding at a low point, or a waterfront exposure each point to a different membrane and a different detail.
- What the rules require. A new or replacement low-slope roof has to meet the city's reflectance values unless an exception applies, and a job that reaches the deck can bring other requirements with it.
- How long you intend to hold the building. A five-year plan and a twenty-year plan justify different money, and it is a fair question for us to ask before recommending anything.
We are not tied to one manufacturer; the product is chosen for each job after the survey. Whatever the system, the written scope names the product, the thickness and the attachment method, so you can compare bids on the same basis.
Systems are only half of a roof
The membrane gets the attention; the details decide whether the roof works. Drains and their layout, insulation and how it is fixed, the flashing at every wall, curb and penetration, the edge metal, and the walkway layout for whoever services the equipment: these are where nearly every leak we attend began, whatever the sheet is made of.
If you are weighing one system against another for a particular building, our guide to choosing a commercial flat roof system sets out the constraints and the lifecycle costs that usually decide it.
Start with the problem rather than the product. If there is a leak now, see commercial roof repair. If the roof is at the end of its life, see replacement. If you want it to last longer, see inspections and maintenance.